Benito Skinner and Mary Beth Barone are taking their iconic bestie dynamic from podcasting to streaming—and now, to BuzzFeed’s studios.

The longtime friends and co-hosts of the popular podcast Ride recently stopped by BuzzFeed for a hilarious game of Celebrity Guess Who?, where they put their pop culture knowledge (and competitive streaks) to the test.

If you’re wondering why you’ve been seeing even more of these icons two lately, it’s because their brand-new Prime Video series, Overcompensating, just dropped and it’s already making waves.

In the show, Benito stars as Benny, a closeted ex-homecoming king trying to figure himself out while navigating college life. Mary Beth plays his blunt, sometimes chaotic older sister Grace, who’s also enrolled at the same university.

Though the two are playing siblings on-screen this time around, their real-life chemistry and comedic timing still shine through… especially in their BuzzFeed challenge. It’s the perfect chaotic teaser for what fans can expect from Overcompensating, which is available to stream now on Prime Video.

PS… we better be getting a season two after that ending, Benny!